Can you keep a secret?

I can. 

I don't always like it … Secrets can be heavy, weighing on your mind, sometimes your heart, especially when someone asks you to help them carry a secret full of pain, but then forgets to let you know when everything is fine and dandy again so you can toss it aside like they already did a week ago or so ("oops, didn't I tell you?") while you've been left carrying this festering thing that's growing larger and getting heavier by the minute as it feeds on your concern and worry about them…

Ahem. Sorry. What I learned from that experience was that it's okay to tell Tom about things that weigh on my heart so heavily …    

But, oh man, if I weren't such a sealed vault, the stories I could tell! Talk about a top blog and bestselling memoir!

However, I've read blog posts and memoirs that made me cringe in embarrassment for the (ex?)friends and family members of the author. Sure, it made for exciting, titillating reading, but at what price?

I'd rather risk obscurity as a writer than hurt (or lose) my family and friends by sharing stories that also belong to them and that they aren't as keen on sharing.

I'm pretty much an open book – but I realize I'm kind of weird that way.

But even if we're 'open books' about our own lives, we're still full of secrets, aren't we? If we're married, have children, belong to a family, have friends … if we've shared experiences or opened our hearts to others, or allowed others to open their hearts to us … we have a collection that's sacred and valuable, and the care we give to that collection is an indication of our character.

I'm walking a fine line as I write my great-great grandfather's story, a story that at one time was a family secret, so secret that my grandmother and her siblings were only aware of scandalous bits and pieces.

But it was his story, after all; he chose to tell it all those years ago, and now it's part of the public domain. But I still feel protective of it, as if it were still a family secret, and so I'm driven to fill in the gaps, to make sure the points he was trying to make in the telling are what get heard before anyone else gets their hands on it and twists them around. I can feel my grandmother and her mother, her father, her grandmother and grandfather and aunts and uncles, all keeping an eye on what I write. I can feel the weight of the secrets and the responsibility of what to share and what to keep in the vault.

Annie b and family cropped

It's pretty heavy. But the good thing is I'm not carrying it alone – I have other family members who help carry the weight of those secrets, and who will help me decide what stays in the vault.

DSC_0040 (Medium)

And that's why I don't mind when others share their secrets with me, and why I'm so grateful for the friends I have who I know will seal up anything I share with them in confidence in their vaults. It lightens the loads. And that's what friends and family are for, isn't it?

"My whole silence is full of prayer."

~Thomas Merton

 

 

 

This is my contribution to the very first ever Prompt Me! Wednesday, hosted by Jillsy, where (in her words) "…one prompt produces free flowing expression from blog to blog… any medium is excepted – words, music, photography, or anything your creativity stirs up! However the prompt moves you, go with it! There will be no wrongs or rights… "

Click on the badge below to go to Jillsy's blog and find out how to join in the fun or to see the other contributions.

Prompt Me! Wednesday

 


 

 

 

 

 

Posted in , , , , ,

7 responses to “On Secrets”

  1. Juana Avatar

    How very interesting that you posted this today. A day when I doubted if I should have told my mother’s story. Well part of it…and oh, if I could talk about it all,I would be a millionaire.
    I am NOT kidding.
    Your story sounds fabulous and I can’t wait to read it. It must be difficult to write a book with so many relatives keeping watch on your pen.
    Makes me wonder…now that I have decided to write my mother’s story,if I really need to consider my family’s opinion, when my heart is pounding to set it free. So I believe we are in the same boat my dear. We will probably not say
    the truth. It will be BASED on a true story.
    P.S. GREAT POST AND that photo is awesome!!!

    Like

  2. Walker Avatar

    Nice take on the prompt! It’s hard to find a way through the story into something that retains the integrity of the story while keeping everyone’s dignity. I am one of those writers who tells a lot, bordering on too much-I do it, in part, to let others see they’re not alone, that we all struggle and we are all flawed. Some days it works, and others… not so much.

    Like

  3. Barbara Shallue Avatar

    Judging from your family's response, they were all very supportive of how you treated your mom's story, and when you write the book, I would listen to their feedback (but also your heart – your opinion matters just as much.) Once long ago, I wrote a short story based on a bit of my mom's life, and that's where I realized even if it's fictionalized, you still have to tread carefully, especially if it's not YOUR story, no matter how much your telling is based on admiration. I don't think that was the case with your post on your mom, though. It's a little easier for me with my book since my gggrandfather wrote his own memoir and everyone personally involved has been gone a long time now. I just have to remember their eyes on me and listen for their voices in my heart.

    Like

  4. Barbara Shallue Avatar

    I think it's a common dilemma for all writers – I'm motivated by the same reasons you are and it was kind of a shock when I realized everyone didn't see it the same way I did! I think you do a great job with the balance – I know you try hard!

    Like

  5. Jillsy Girl Avatar

    Every time you post about your book, I get more and more intrigued! I can’t wait til it hits the stands! 🙂
    It must be a fine line for many writers when it comes to revealing true life events. Although, there are also many who couldn’t care less about exposing everything or using distortion to create interest. Just as long as they make a buck. Like the books about Lady Di. Pure sensationalism.

    Like

  6. Barbara Shallue Avatar

    I know it's a fine line for me, because I think truth is so much more interesting than fiction! But I'm always worried I'll hurt someone's feelings. Oh, I hate those kinds of books (and magazine articles) that have no sense of respect to privacy – and the whole Wiki-Leaks thing makes me angry – I think there are some things we don't need to know about!

    Like

  7. deb @ talk at the table Avatar

    Barbara,
    Thanks for reading and taking the time to comment on my post.
    I like your site here… and I completely agree with you in this.

    Like

Leave a comment